International Fishers
  • International Fishers
  • Khmer
    • CBI 2015
    • CPTI 2015
    • CPTI 2022
    • Khmer Audio
  • Khmer Blog
  • Blog
  • Radio
    • Reason Radio
    • Truth Talks 1 to 6 >
      • Truth Talk 1
      • Truth Talk 2
      • Truth Talk 3
      • Truth Talk 4
      • Truth Talk 5
      • Truth Talk 6
    • Truth Talks 7 to 12 >
      • Truth Talk 7
      • Truth Talk 8
      • Truth Talk 9
      • Truth Talk 10
      • Truth Talk 11
      • Truth Talk 12
    • Truth Talks 13 to 19 >
      • Truth Talk 13
      • Truth Talk 14
      • Truth Talk 15
      • Truth Talk 16
      • Truth Talk 17
      • Truth Talk 18
      • Truth Talk 19
    • Truth Talks 20 to 26 >
      • Truth Talk 20
      • Truth Talk 21
      • Truth Talk 22
      • Truth Talk 23
      • Truth Talk 24
      • Truth Talk 25
      • Truth Talk 26
    • Relationships 1 to 6 >
      • Relationships 1
      • Relationships 2
      • Relationships 3
      • Relationships 4
      • Relationships 5
      • Relationships 6
    • Relationships 7 to 12 >
      • Relationships 7
      • Relationships 8
      • Relationships 9
      • Relationships 10
      • Relationships 11
      • Relationships 12
    • Relationships 13 to 19 >
      • Relationships 13
      • Relationships 14
      • Relationships 15
      • Relationships 16
      • Relationships 17
      • Relationships 18
      • Relationships 19
    • Relationships 20 to 26 >
      • Relationships 20
      • Relationships 21
      • Relationships 22
      • Relationships 23
      • Relationships 24
      • Relationships 25
      • Relationships 26
    • Experience 1 to 6 >
      • Experience 1
      • Experience 2
      • Experience 3
      • Experience 4
      • Experience 5
      • Experience 6
    • Experience 7 to 12 >
      • Experience 7
      • Experience 8
      • Experience 9
      • Experience 10
      • Experience 11
      • Experience 12
    • Experience 13 to 19 >
      • Experience 13
      • Experience 14
      • Experience 15
      • Experience 16
      • Experience 17
      • Experience 18
      • Experience 19
    • Experience 20 to 26 >
      • Experience 20
      • Experience 21
      • Experience 22
      • Experience 23
      • Experience 24
      • Experience 25
      • Experience 26
  • Videos
    • Archaeology and Bible
    • Bible Instructions
    • Technology >
      • Flight English
      • Flight Khmer
    • DNA >
      • DNA English
      • DNA Japanese
      • DNA Khmer
    • History >
      • History English
      • History Khmer
      • History Spanish
    • Life >
      • Life English
      • Life Japanese
      • Life Khmer
      • Life Spanish
    • Rescue >
      • Rescue English
      • Rescue Khmer
    • Real Joy (Khmer Audio)
    • Samoeun Intal
  • Chinese
  • English
  • Japanese
  • Spanish
  • Missions
  • Eternal Impact
  • International Fishers
  • Khmer
    • CBI 2015
    • CPTI 2015
    • CPTI 2022
    • Khmer Audio
  • Khmer Blog
  • Blog
  • Radio
    • Reason Radio
    • Truth Talks 1 to 6 >
      • Truth Talk 1
      • Truth Talk 2
      • Truth Talk 3
      • Truth Talk 4
      • Truth Talk 5
      • Truth Talk 6
    • Truth Talks 7 to 12 >
      • Truth Talk 7
      • Truth Talk 8
      • Truth Talk 9
      • Truth Talk 10
      • Truth Talk 11
      • Truth Talk 12
    • Truth Talks 13 to 19 >
      • Truth Talk 13
      • Truth Talk 14
      • Truth Talk 15
      • Truth Talk 16
      • Truth Talk 17
      • Truth Talk 18
      • Truth Talk 19
    • Truth Talks 20 to 26 >
      • Truth Talk 20
      • Truth Talk 21
      • Truth Talk 22
      • Truth Talk 23
      • Truth Talk 24
      • Truth Talk 25
      • Truth Talk 26
    • Relationships 1 to 6 >
      • Relationships 1
      • Relationships 2
      • Relationships 3
      • Relationships 4
      • Relationships 5
      • Relationships 6
    • Relationships 7 to 12 >
      • Relationships 7
      • Relationships 8
      • Relationships 9
      • Relationships 10
      • Relationships 11
      • Relationships 12
    • Relationships 13 to 19 >
      • Relationships 13
      • Relationships 14
      • Relationships 15
      • Relationships 16
      • Relationships 17
      • Relationships 18
      • Relationships 19
    • Relationships 20 to 26 >
      • Relationships 20
      • Relationships 21
      • Relationships 22
      • Relationships 23
      • Relationships 24
      • Relationships 25
      • Relationships 26
    • Experience 1 to 6 >
      • Experience 1
      • Experience 2
      • Experience 3
      • Experience 4
      • Experience 5
      • Experience 6
    • Experience 7 to 12 >
      • Experience 7
      • Experience 8
      • Experience 9
      • Experience 10
      • Experience 11
      • Experience 12
    • Experience 13 to 19 >
      • Experience 13
      • Experience 14
      • Experience 15
      • Experience 16
      • Experience 17
      • Experience 18
      • Experience 19
    • Experience 20 to 26 >
      • Experience 20
      • Experience 21
      • Experience 22
      • Experience 23
      • Experience 24
      • Experience 25
      • Experience 26
  • Videos
    • Archaeology and Bible
    • Bible Instructions
    • Technology >
      • Flight English
      • Flight Khmer
    • DNA >
      • DNA English
      • DNA Japanese
      • DNA Khmer
    • History >
      • History English
      • History Khmer
      • History Spanish
    • Life >
      • Life English
      • Life Japanese
      • Life Khmer
      • Life Spanish
    • Rescue >
      • Rescue English
      • Rescue Khmer
    • Real Joy (Khmer Audio)
    • Samoeun Intal
  • Chinese
  • English
  • Japanese
  • Spanish
  • Missions
  • Eternal Impact

Apologist Abroad

Darryl's thoughts on the Christian Faith, Facts, and World Events

Why I Can't Trust Brian Simmons' Passion "Translation"

8/25/2021

0 Comments

 
Christian unity is very important to me.  That is why more than a decade ago I wrote a book in Cambodia with an English title: Discerning Essential Doctrines and Preserving Unity.  In the process of researching for that book. I came to the realization from Scripture that genuine unity must be balanced with discernment and be built on a foundation of truth, particularly the truth of God's Word. 

In my work as an apologist/missionary in Cambodia, I use and value a wide variety of translations.  However, I cannot trust or use Brian Simmons' The Passion Translation (TPT).  Brian Simmons is a charismatic and  the TPT reflects some of that background.  I myself am not anti-charismatic.  I actually teach apologetics at an Assembly of God Bible school in Cambodia (and at a Presbyterian seminary).

"My dear friends, many false prophets have gone out into the world. So do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see if they are from God." 1 John 4:1 NCV

Brian Simmons makes many claims. Some of the claims can be tested and some cannot because there are no witnesses.  I believe that it is Biblically appropriate to test his testable statements and see if they are truthful and then we can decide whether or not we should take his untestable claims at face value or not.

​"I will come to you for the third time. “Every case must be proved by two or three witnesses.”  2 Corinthians 13:1-2 NCV

I also believe that in order to be fair to Brian Simmons, he should be allowed to speak for himself as much as possible.  This is why I prefer video quotations so I can be more certain that he is not being taken out of context etc.  Pastor/Apologist Mike Winger did a great job of interviewing Bible scholars with experience in Bible translation on his YouTube channel.  Here are some videos on the subject that you can watch on your own. www.youtube.com/results?search_query=mike+winger+passion+translation

The only downside of Mike Winger's videos is that most of them are long so the average person may not be willing to devote the time to watch them.   For this reason, I have distilled my thoughts based on his videos into this blog article.
  1. Simmons claims to that the NT was written in Aramaic.  He also claims to have access to Aramaic manuscripts that predate the Greek manuscripts.  Multiple qualified witnesses (Bible scholars who participated in the translation of other translations) say this is false.  
Links to Mike Winger's videos (click on the time link to watch the video on YouTube):​
  • Dr. Craig Bloomberg 12:38 This is REALLY bad. Brian Simmons is deceiving people about what "all the scholars" think. 
  • Dr. Brad Bitner 18:20 Simmons badly wrong about “Aramaic” 
  • Dr. Darrell Bock 5:15 The CENTRAL issue of Simmons misleading people about using Aramaic in Ephesians.  
Brian Simmons Makes Claims About His Background (2-4)

2.  Simmons claims to be a linguist. Don Pederson  and Jerry McDaniels of New Tribes Mission/Ethnos 360 say this is false.

3. Simmons claims to have been directly engaged in the translation the indigenous language Paya Kuna translation.  NTM (multiple witnesses)  says this is false, he was a church planter.

4. Simmons claims to have completed the Paya Kuna translation in the late 1980s.  Moody Bible Institute says it was not completed until 1995 after Simmons left the organization (Don Pederson). 

Witnesses for Claims 2-4:
https://youtu.be/IBmS5ywXtkY

5. Simmons and his publisher claim that The Passion Translation is a translation.  Multiple witnesses say this is false, it is at best a paraphrase.  Multiple witnesses, Bible scholars, say that it is misleading and goes beyond the original meaning in places when compared to original languages. 
  • Dr. Darrell Bock 2:50 Why it is not truthful to call TPT a “translation." 
  • Dr. Brad Bitner 11:45 TPT is not a real translation 
  • Dr. Craig Bloomberg  7:51 Is TPT misleading people when it calls itself a “translation"?
Based on the above reasons and more, I cannot trust Brian Simmons' testable claims about his background, the Aramaic, and his "translation".  Therefore, I must also doubt Brian Simmons' claims of supernatural "downloads." 
Watch:
7:39 Brian Simmons’ wild claims about TPT 

Since TPT is almost completely based on the credibility of Brian Simmons it is on a sandy foundation.  Even if it were based on a team of qualified translators, which it isn’t, I still would not accept it because of its false claims about the Aramaic and being a "translation".  

If people get attached to TPT they will also get attached to Brian Simmons.  What if he is exposed as Ravi Zacharias was?  People may lose their confidence in the Word of God.

You have heard from Brian Simmons. You have heard from the witnesses.  Who do you believe?

As for me, as an apologist, I cannot trust or use TPT.  I also strongly discourage anyone else from using it, especially in Bible teaching or sermons.  
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    E-Mail Updates
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Darryl Record

    A Christian Apologist, Author, Missionary, Husband, and Father. Darryl has an MA in Christian Apologetics from Biola University (CA), an MA in TESOL from Azusa Pacific University (CA), and a BA in Political Science from Truman State University (MO). 

    Archives

    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    August 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    November 2020
    September 2020
    June 2020
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    January 2017
    October 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    April 2015

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed